Cancer therapy should transform to place greater emphasis on patient voice

Health Industry Hub | May 25, 2022 |
[Total: 1    Average: 4/5]

Medical: A patient’s perspective on their physical health provides a better indication of their response to cancer treatment than clinician-based tools, a new study has found, highlighting the importance of shared decision-making in the treatment process.

Lead author Natansh Modi, NHMRC PhD candidate in the Clinical Cancer Epidemiology Lab at Flinders University, said “An essential component of patient-centred care, shared decision making is a process in which the clinician and patient collate and discuss the available evidence on the benefits and harms of treatments, ensuring the most appropriate and informed decision is made for the patient.”

The American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the European Society for Medical Oncology (ESMO) have highlighted the identification of strategies that predict response and toxicity to anticancer therapies as key research priorities. Two tools can be used during shared-decision making: the Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status (ECOG PS), a tool interpreted by the doctor, and patient-reported outcomes (PROs), structured tools whereby a patient self-reports their perspective on their physical, social, emotional, and functional abilities.

“PROs are generally used as secondary data in clinical trials to help with interpreting results; however, they have recently shown to be important in providing a prognosis to the patient for cancer types including bladder, lung and skin cancers, but their value to HER2-positive advanced breast cancer had yet to be fully explored,” said Mr Modi.

Emerging compliance and ethics trends set to influence the pharma sector

Published in the journal ESMO Open, the study pooled data from several trials to look at almost 3,000 patients who underwent drug treatments for human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2)-positive breast cancer.

“We found that a number of patient-reported outcomes, including those on physical well-being and mental health, were identified as significant factors associated with either the patient’s overall survival of cancer, with cancer not progressing or severe adverse events during treatment,” said Mr Modi.

“The results indicate that information provided by the patients themselves was better able to predict their reaction to the treatment and their overall prognosis than the clinician-interpreted scores. Significantly, patient-reported physical well-being was found to be the most useful patient-reported outcome in determining a diagnosis for all available treatment outcomes,” he noted.

The study found very different results between the clinician-based data and the patient-reported data, with many clinicians overestimating their patient’s physical wellbeing.

“We determined that around 70% of the patients who their clinicians defined as ‘fully active, and able to carry on all pre-disease performance without restrictions’ went on to report limitations in their physical well-being status when asked to self-report,” noted Mr Modi.

The authors said the research highlights the importance of listening to patients, with both types of tools providing helpful independent prognosis information.

“This study demonstrates that patient-reported physical well-being can predict prognosis better than clinician-interpreted ECOG PS. It is, therefore, essential that clinical practice transforms to place a greater emphasis on the patient’s perspective and voice,” added Mr Modi.

“By combining patient-reported questionnaires and clinically interpreted measures, we can provide the best clinical insights that allow for shared decision-making in cancer treatment, while also enhancing the design of future clinical trials.”

The Health Industry Hub news and professional development content are copyright protected and access is provided under individual user licenses. For more information, visit and T&Cs.

Human Resources

Only 29% of employees say their leader shows ‘human leadership’

Health Industry Hub | June 24, 2022 |

Human Resources: A survey of more than 230 HR leaders revealed that 90% believe that to succeed in today’s work environment, […]


News & Trends - Medical Technology

MedTech News - Quantum HealthCare appointed as ANZ distributor for new medical technology

Quantum HealthCare appointed as ANZ distributor for new medical technology

Health Industry Hub | June 24, 2022 |

MedTech News: Alfred Health Hospital in Australia is set to receive first-in-nation portable MRI systems for point-of-care brain scans. US-based […]


News & Trends - Medical Technology

Medtech News - Medical association continues its strong opposition to Honeysuckle Health in legal proceedings

Medical association continues its strong opposition to Honeysuckle Health in legal proceedings

Health Industry Hub | June 24, 2022 |

MedTech News: The Australian Medical Association (AMA) is involved in proceedings before the Australian Competition Tribunal, opposing an attempt by […]


News & Trends - Medical Technology

Medtech News -

Medtronic award winner secures approval in diagnosis of gut disorders

Health Industry Hub | June 24, 2022 |

MedTech News: New Zealand based company and winner of the inaugural Medtronic APAC Innovation Challenge (MAIC) has received FDA approval […]


This content is copyright protected