New insights shatter ED myths: Non-urgent patients not the culprit behind overcrowding

MedTech & Diagnostics News: The widely held belief that non-urgent patients are clogging up emergency departments (EDs) and stealing precious resources from those truly in need, has been debunked by a comprehensive analysis of emergency department data. The new research uncovers a complex reality behind ED overcrowding that challenges conventional wisdom.

For years, the finger of blame has been pointed at so-called “GP-type patients” – individuals whose medical issues seemed better suited for a general practice than the frenetic hustle of an emergency room. But experts now assert that the narrative is far from accurate. The study, led by the Nepean Hospital, delved into data, rigorously dissecting the nature of ED visits and scrutinising the actual dynamics at play.

Surprisingly, the analysis revealed that the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare’s (AIHW) criteria for categorising patients as “GP-type” are not a reliable gauge of whether these individuals genuinely require GP-level care. Of the 6,483 patients studied, a staggering 1,546 – more than three-quarters of those deemed suitable for GP care by AIHW standards – were found to require a higher level of medical attention.

Co-author Dr James Mallows expressed his goal for undertaking the research. “We were confronted with a lack of clarity surrounding the issue of ED overcrowding. Many believe that non-urgent cases are the culprits, but our findings challenge that notion,” Dr Mallows explained.

He further emphasised that these patients are typically addressed through specialised care pathways within the ED, further underscoring that the bed capacity shortage, not non-urgent patients, is the primary contributor to access block.

Dr Jillann Farmer, a GP and emergency locum, concurred with the findings, highlighting the substantial proportion of bed occupancy caused by patients awaiting placement in aged care or National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) accommodations. The state-federal division of healthcare responsibilities is cited as a central hurdle in effectively addressing this crisis. Dr Mallows pinpointed the intergovernmental squabble as a catalyst for misconceptions about the root cause of ED congestion, leading to misguided attempts to resolve the issue.

“We’ve got to stop a situation where health ministers can dump the blame into someone else’s sector. The health ministers are jointly accountable for the health of all Australians. And they just need to stop it,” Dr Farmer concluded.

In reimagining healthcare across the entire patient journey, Health Industry Hub^TM is the only one-stop-hub bringing the diversity of Pharma, MedTech, Diagnostics & Biotech sectors together to inspire meaningful change.

The content on Health Industry Hub is copyright protected and should only be accessed under individual user licenses. To subscribe, please click here and visit T&Cs here.